WHAT IS BLEPHAROSPASM?
Also known as Benign Essential Blepharospasm, it is a condition that causes involuntary squeezing of the muscles in the eyelids, including the frown muscles. In some patients, other facial muscles may also be involved. Patients with blepharospasm generally have dry eyes and the spasms are exacerbated by bright lights.
Blepharospasm.
Patel B.C.K., Anderson R.L.
Ophthalmic Practice 1993; 11: 293-312.
Blepharospasm and related facial movement disorders.
Patel B.C.K., Anderson R.L.
Current Opinion in Ophthalmology 1995;6:86-99.
“Well, the last time I had a picture taken I could hardly see my eyes because of the weight of heavy eyelid. Then I paid attention to how I was actually using my eyes and I really noticed when I was looking at anything especially the computer I was straining my forehead to see better. Since I have had it done I no longer have to lift the forehead and tilt my head to see. It is amazing! I love…” D. Rock 63 Yrs Old with Fat Droopy Eyes – Salt Lake City, UT
HOW DOES BLEPHAROSPASM PRESENT?
The earliest sign of blepharospasm is a simple increase in the blink rate with only intermittent eyelid spasms: this is often missed and patient may be diagnosed with a neuropsychiatric disorder like depression or anxiety. Over time this increases to more uncontrolled spasms. If untreated, the spasms are severe enough to make people functionally blind with severe overaction of the facial muscles and may also lead to depression.
WHAT IS APRAXIA OF EYELID OPENING?
Blepharospasm: Past, Present, Future.
Anderson R.L , Patel B.C.K, Holds JB, Jordan DR.
Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg 1998;14(5):305-317.
“I had a excellent eye lift done by Dr. Patel. He knows what he is doing and is very pleasant. Dr.Patel was easy to get an appointment and he works with you. The office staff was very pleasant and made you feel calm.” D. Gull Highly recommended for eye lift surgery – Salt Lake City, UT
INFORMATION ABOUT BLEPHAROSPASM FOR OTHER DOCTORS
The early symptoms of blepharospasm include increased blink rate (77%), eyelid spasms (66%), eye irritation (55%), midfacial or lower facial spasm (59%), brow spasm (24%), and eyelid tic (22%). Symptoms commonly preceding diagnosis include tearing, eye irritation, photophobia, and vague ocular pain. While these complaints are common in the average ophthalmology practice, awareness of this disorder and proper suspicion may aid in early diagnosis. Conditions relieving blepharospasm included sleep (75%), relaxation (55%), inferior gaze (27%), artificial tears (24%), traction on eyelids (22%), talking (22%), singing (20%), and humming (19%). Comorbid diagnoses include dry eyes (49%)
and other neurologic disease (8%).
Blepharospasm and related diseases.
Patel B.C.K., Anderson R.L.
Focal Points, Clinical Modules for Ophthalmologists 2000;18:5;1-13.
BLEPHAROSPASM: HISTORICAL DETAILS
Henry Meige. a French neurologist described a condition in 1910 characterized by blepharospasm and facial. Mandibular, oral. lingual and laryngeal spasms and called it “spasm facial median”. Although Meige has been credited with the first description of blepharospasm. Talkow in 1870 described a patient with similar findings as did Wood in presentations at the Universitv ofPennsvlvania in the 1870s. We know from the paintings by the Flemish artist Brueghel and other clinical descriptions that the condition was known as long ago as the 16th centurv. Indeed. the frustration associated with the treatment of blepharospasm is graphicallv illustrated bv Gerold’s suggestion in 1843. In a counsel of desperation, Gerold suggested treating intractable blepharospasm by “neglecting the spasm and carving a hole in the upper lid opposite the pupil through which the unfonunatc patient could peep”. Whether this inauspicious procedure was ever undertaken is unknown.
HOW COMMON IS BLEPHAROSPASM?
It is estimated that there are at least 50,000 cases of blepharospasm in the United States, with about 2000 new cases diagnosed every year. The prevalence of blepharospasm in the population is
approximately 5 in 100,000.
IS BLEPHAROSPASM HEREDITORY?
Blepharospasm in most cases is isolated but there is a positive family history of blepharospasm in some cases. We do not think this disease is “hereditary” in that there is not a genetic transmission of this disease.
WHAT IS THE CAUSE OF BLEPHAROSPASM?
WHAT IS THE NORMAL PROGRESSION OF BLEPHAROSPASM?
At onset, there is increased frequency of blinking, particularly in response to a variety of common stimuli, including wind, air pollution, sunlight, noise, movements of the head or eyes, and in response to stress or the environment. Patients may complain of photophobia and ocular surface discomfort, and especially of dry eye symptoms. These symptoms progress over a variable period to include involuntary unilateral spasms, which later become bilateral. Patients may report that they are disabled to the point where they have stopped watching television, reading, driving, and/or walking. A family history positive for dystonia or blepharospasm further aids in the diagnosis. Blepharospasm commonly is associated with dystonic movements of other facial muscles. Anatomic changes associated with longstanding blepharospasm include eyelid and brow ptosis, dermatochalasis, entropion, and canthal tendon abnormalities.
HOW IS BLEPHAROSPASM MANAGED?
- Information on blepharospasm may be obtained from the Benign Essential Blepharospasm Research Foundation: Formed in 1981, the purpose of this foundation is to undertake, promote, develop, and search for a cure for benign essential blepharospasm (BEB), Meige syndrome, and related disorders. This organization is located in Beaumont, Texas, and promotes awareness of these conditions to both physicians and the general public, organizes support groups throughout the world, and obtains funding for research and education.
- Although there is no oral medication that cures blepharospasm, drugs such as lorazepam, clonazepam and Artane may be prescribed and may be useful as adjunctive treatment.
- Botulinum toxin: treatment with botulinum toxin is regarded as the most effective treatment of choice for the rapid but temporary improvement in the spasms. More than 95% of patients report significant improvement
- with these injections. The toxin is the product of the bacteria Clostridium botulinum and works by affecting the release of acetylcholine at neuro-muscluar junctions.
- FL 41 filtered lenses: we have found that certain filters in spectacle lenses make patients much more comfortable and less light-sensitive. Information on this may be obtained from: Health Care. Utah.edu (Adams WH, Digre KB, Patel BC, Anderson RL, Warner JE, Katz BJ. The evaluation of light sensitivity in benign essential blepharospasm. Am J Ophthalmol. 2006 Jul;142(1):82-87. PubMed PMID: 16815254).
- Surgery: some patients may need a limited myectomy to reduce the degree of squeezing. A complete myectomy is performed much more rarely now.
- Some patients benefit from surgical management of the effects of blepharospasm, namely brow ptosis, ptosis and dermatochalasis, and in some patients, ectropion.
- In apraxia of eyelid opening, there is difficulty with opening the eyelids even when the botulinum toxin is working well: in such patients, frontalis slings are utilized to aid the opening of the eyelids.
TESTING DIFFERENT FILTERS
DIFFERENT FL-41 FILTERS
Our team at the Moran Eye Center, University of Utah showed how these FL-41 lenses are often useful in patients with light-sensitivity in blepharospasm.
WHAT IS THE COMMONEST TREATMENT FOR BLEPHAROSPASM?
Botulinum toxin is an approved treatment for blepharospasm and hemifacial spasm in the United States and Canada. This is a toxin produced by the bacteria Clostridium botulinum. It weakens the muscles by blocking nerve impulses transmitted from the nerve endings of the muscles. When it is used to treat blepharospasm, minute doses of botulinum toxin are injected intramuscularly into several sites above and below the eyes. The sites of the injection will vary slightly from patient to patient and according to physician preference. They are usually given on the eyelid, the brow, and the muscles under the lower lid. The injections are carried out with a very fine needle. Benefits begin in 3 – 7 days after the treatment and last for an average of three to four months. Long-term follow-up studies have shown it to be a very safe and effective treatment, with up to 90 percent of patients obtaining almost complete relief of their blepharospasm. Side effects include drooping of the eyelid (ptosis), blurred vision, and double vision (diplopia). Tearing may occur. All are transient and recover spontaneously. Providing the dose is kept small and the injections carried out at a minimum of three-month intervals, repeated treatments remain effective over a long period of time. All patients will experience an increased degree of dryness for the first few days to a few weeks after the botulinum toxin injections and will need topical artificial tears and lubricating ointment at night.
WHAT TYPES OF BOTULINUM TOXINS ARE AVAILABLE AND APPROVED?
Botulinum toxin type-A, originally called Oculinum (this same substance is now called onabotulinumtoxinA or Botox) for the treatment of strabismus and blepharospasm in 1989. The FDA also approved the use of onabotulinumtoxinA for the treatment of cervical dystonia in 2000, and for the treatment of spasticity in the flexor muscles of the elbow, wrist, and fingers in 2010.
In 2000, the FDA approved the use of a form of BoNT type-B as rimabotulinumtoxinB (or Myobloc) for the treatment of cervical dystonia. Since then, the FDA has approved two other forms of BoNT type-A. AbobotulinumtoxinA, or Dysport, was approved in 2009 for the treatment of cervical dystonia. And, in 2010, the FDA approved the use of incobotulinumtoxinA, or Xeomin, for the treatment of cervical dystonia and blepharospasm.
Diagnosis and treatment of blepharospasm.
Patel B.C.K., Weinstein G.S., Anderson R.L.
Nesi F.A., Della Rocca R.C., Lisman R.D.. (eds)
Smith’s Ophthalmic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Mosby-Year Book, Inc., Philadelphia, 2nd edition 1997;319-335.
WHAT ARE THE SECONDARY EFFECTS OF BLEPHAROSPASM?
Besides the squeezing of the eyelids (blepharospasm) and difficulty opening the eyelids (apraxia of eyelid opening), secondary effects from the squeezing as well as age-related effects can lead to brow ptosis, ptosis, dermatochalasis and lower eyelid laxity or entropion. These secondary changes may need to be addressed surgically to allow the brows and eyelids to sit at a more normal position so that the eyelids may open more effectively and also so that the effects of the botulinum toxin are acceptable.
Secondary effects of blepharospasm with ptosis, dermatochalasis, overaction of the corrugator and procerus muscles causing medial brow ptosis and lower eyelid laxity.
WHEN SURGERY IS NEEDED: OUR APPROACH AS DESIGNED BY US ABOUT 15 YEARS AGO
the results were less than ideal.
We address the problem of blepharospasm, when surgery is indicated, in a logical anatomical, physiological and individualized basis. The aim of any such surgery should be:
- Correct the secondary effects of blepharospasm (brow ptosis, ptosis, dermatochalasis, lower eyelid laxity).
- Reduce the mass of the orbicularis that mainly contributes to the squeezing of the eyelids. This will vary from patient-to-patient and this is where careful assessment and planning are so important.
- Improve the appearance of the face.
- Protect closure of the eyelids at all cost.
- Improve lower eyelid laxity.
- Avoid defects that create hollows and excavations.
Our surgical approaches were developed from the cosmetic procedures we designed to perform brow lifts, eyelid cosmetic surgery, lower eyelid cosmetic surgery, cheek lifts and lower facial surgery (facelifts, etc). Using these principles and approaches, all patients are treated as if they are undergoing cosmetic surgery (to achieve as nice a cosmetic result as possible!).
The techniques involve the use of endoscopes, limited myectomy, partial manipulation of the corrugator and procerus muscles, repositioning the lower eyelids AND the cheeks and avoidance of excavations. The results look like the following photos:
Before (left) and after surgery for blepharospasm. Patient underwent endoscopic brow lifts, endoscopic weakening of the corrugator and procerus muscles, blepharoplasty with ptosis repair and limited myectomy, lower eyelid elevation and tightening, minimal lower myectomy (to prevent lower eyelid retraction and ectropion), and cheek elevation to support the lower eyelids.
Surgical management of essential blepharospasm.
Patel BCK.
Otolaryngol Clin North Am. 2005 Oct;38(5):1075-98..
Surgical management of blepharospasm.
Patel B.C.K., Langer P., El Gazayerli E., Anderson R.L.
Naugle T.C. (ed)
Diagnosis and Management of Oculoplastic and Orbital Disorders, Kugler Publications, Amsterdam/New York; 1996:165-178.
WHAT CAN I EXPECT IF I NEED TO UNDERGO SUCH SURGERY?
- Reduced squeezing of the orbicularis and corrugator and procerus muscles. However, the surgery does NOT eliminate the squeezing completely.
- You will still need injections of botulinum toxin to keep the spasms under control. This is because blepharospasm is a CENTRAL disease (in the brain!) and not a peripheral disease. By performing surgery, one can only hope to reduce the effects of the central disease. This is where the earlier surgeries failed as attempts were made to completely eradicate all muscles and nerves, resulting in secondary defects and sometimes severe problems.
- EVERYONE will experience some degree of increased dryness, necessitating increased use of artificial tears and ointment and, sometimes plugging of two or more of your puncta (tear ducts).
- EVERYONE will experience some difficulty closing their eyelids to some degree. This is because of simple anatomy and physiology. If you remove some of the closing muscles (orbicularis oculi muscle), then there WILL be some weakness of closure. Furthermore, if you correct the ptosis and dermatochalasis, the lids will be more open and together with some weakness of the orbicularis muscle, there will be need to Florence Nightingale your eyes and the surrounding tissues. We will give you all the guidance. Healing is slow but sure.
- You may be more sensitive to light since your eyelids will be more open (which is a good thing!).
- If you have marked apraxia of eyelid opening, you may need frontalis slings to allow you to better open your eyelids.
Surgical Management of Essential Blepharospasm.
Patel B.C.K., Anderson R.L.
Mauriello J. (ed)
Unfavorable Results of Eyelid and Lacrimal Surgery: Prevention and Management , Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford, 2000; 181-193.
Surgical Management of Blepharospasm
Patel B.C.K.
Katowitz.J (Ed)
Facial Plastic Surgery 2005
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Over 50% of patients who develop dystonia of the eyelid closing musculature (i.e., blepharospasm) will exhibit spread to the lower face, jaw musculature, or neck within 5 years of disease onset.
Isolated neck lifts may be performed with sedation anesthesia or general anesthesia.
The female to male ratio of involvement in this disease is 1.8:1.
Two thirds of patients are 60 years or older. However, blepharospasm has also been diagnosed in children and young adults.
Possibly: there are no controlled scientific studies that have shown a predictable and reliable effect of these treatments. However, if there is no active harm (there isn’t), then there is no reason for patients to try these other modalities of treatment.
An interesting study was done by putting a surgical screw into the temple bone on the principle that many patients can keep their eyelids open by pushing at this point. Initial enthusiasm has abated as many surgeons have been unable to replicate the professed results.
These claims have certainly been made. In my experience, one can improve the degree of squeezing and improve not only the ability to open the eyelids but also the effects of the botulinum toxin with a carefully considered limited myectomy. A full myectomy can lead to numerous problems of lagophthalmos, corneal exposure, conreal ulcers, ectropion, etc and is therefor only rarely undertaken. I find that very few patient can be completely weaned off botulinum toxin injections after any kind of myectomy surgery. Be careful of false promises.
We designed and presented our work on a functional and aesthetic approach to surgical management of blepharospasm ONLY when specifically indicated: in this approach, a limited myectomy of the upper eyelid and the procerus and corrugator muscles is combined with an endoscopic brow lift to provide a better position and support to the brows, which makes it easier for patients to open their eyelid. It also allows future botulinum toxin injections to work better. The scars from this type of surgery are much better and results more reliable. However, a careful assessment of the response to botulinum toxins, clinical examination and assessment of the anatomical structures and health of the tear film and eyelid positions have to be considered before undertaking such surgery.
As the disease progresses in many patients, it is often necessary to increase the dose of the botulinum toxin. True resistance is rarely seen. In some patients we may switch you from one type of botulinum toxin to another as some patients seem to get a better effect with one kind or another.
The effects of botulinum toxin injections have been shown to take effect by day 3 to day 5 and will last for about three months. However, in some patients, the useful effects only last six weeks, and in others, up to four to five months. Taking averages into account, insurance companies have determined that they only cover injections 91 days after injections are administered.
WE ARE HERE FOR YOU
CONTACT DR. PATEL
Do you have questions or need more answers?
Contact Info
Dr. BCK Patel MD, FRCS
1025E 3300S
Salt Lake City, Utah 84106, USA
(801) 413-3599 (phone/text)
E-Mail: bckpatelmd@gmail.com
bckpatel.info
Dr. BCK Patel MD, FRCS
617 E Riverside Dr Suite 101
Saint George, UT 84790, USA
(435) 215-0014
E: drbckpatel@gmail.com
